The Lovenhall RegistryThe LovenhallRegistry
Lovenhall Watch

Which Watches Hold Their Value?

What the watches people actually own fetch on the secondary market, against what they cost new — dated, sourced and read maker by maker.

7 makers readDated and sourcedFree · no account

The short answer

Of the eight Swiss makers in Morgan Stanley's value-retention report, built on WatchCharts data, only three averaged above retail at the end of June 2026: Patek Philippe about 15% over, Rolex about 10% and Audemars Piguet about 3%. Cartier sat about 27% below, Omega about 32%, and Tudor, Vacheron Constantin and IWC 26–38% below; by the end of September the top three stood at about 16%, 10% and 6% over. Outside the report, a TAG Heuer Carrera Chronograph was listed secondhand in November 2026 at a median of about 68% of its list price, and Bob's Watches listed its Longines 31–43% under retail. For your own watch, Watch Scanner & Valuator — Lovenhall’s watch identifier app, free to try on iPhone, iPad & Android — recognizes the maker and model family from a photo and estimates what it fetches.

Figures reviewed November 2026

Watch Scanner & Valuator

Holding it now? Point the camera at it — Watch Scanner & Valuator does the rest.

App StoreGoogle Play

A watch's resale value is set by the reference, not the maker — but the maker decides how far any reference can go. The makers below behave very differently once a watch leaves the boutique.

Brand averages hide the spread. A steel Rolex Daytona, listed at $16,900, sold for $30,000–40,000 at one large US dealer in mid-2026 — close to twice its list — while yellow-gold Day-Date 40s were offered below their $48,000 list. Patek Philippe's Aquanaut collection averaged about 90% above retail in June 2026, its Calatrava and Complications about 34% below. So each maker's page reads its lines one by one, with every figure dated.

Every figure here is an indicative range for honest condition — never an appraisal and never a quotation. The calculator gives a range from a watch's tier, condition and papers; these pages add what the name on the dial does to it.

Side by side

How the makers compare in 2026

Against retail, maker by maker
MakerPre-owned vs retail, average (Q2 2026)Holds bestHolds worst
Patek PhilippeAbout 15% aboveAquanaut and Nautilus (about 90% and 74% above)Calatrava and Complications (about 34% below)
RolexAbout 10% aboveLand-Dweller, Oyster Perpetual and Daytona (about 34–36% above)Sea-Dweller (about 21% below)
Audemars PiguetAbout 3% aboveRoyal Oak (about 36% above)Code 11.59 (about 33% below)
CartierAbout 27% belowNot reported by collectionNot reported by collection
OmegaAbout 32% belowNot reported by collectionNot reported by collection
TAG HeuerNot in the index; a Carrera Chronograph listed at a median about 32% below list (November 2026)Automatic chronographs: Carrera and MonacoQuartz Formula 1 models
LonginesNot in the index; Bob's Watches listings 31–43% below retail (November 2026)Spirit and Legend Diver; 1940s 13ZN chronographs at auctionQuartz Conquest V.H.P.

Average pre-owned price against current retail for the eight Swiss makers in Morgan Stanley's value-retention report on WatchCharts data, snapshot of 29 June 2026, as reported by DMARGE, WatchTime and WatchGuys; collection figures from the same report via WatchGuys. In the September 2026 edition Patek Philippe stood at 16.3%, Rolex at 10.3% and Audemars Piguet at 5.9% above retail. TAG Heuer and Longines are not in that report; their rows were read in November 2026 from asking prices against US list prices, not from sales.

Questions we are asked

Which watches hold their value best?
Steel sports watches from Patek Philippe, Rolex and Audemars Piguet. Of the eight Swiss makers in Morgan Stanley's value-retention report, those three were the only ones averaging above retail in June 2026, and their Aquanaut, Nautilus, Royal Oak, Daytona and GMT-Master collections all averaged above list.
Rolex vs Omega, Cartier and Patek Philippe: which holds value better?
Patek Philippe holds best of the four: about 15% above retail on average at the end of June 2026, against Rolex about 10% above, Cartier about 27% below and Omega about 32% below (Morgan Stanley's value-retention report, WatchCharts data). Within each maker the reference matters more than the name — a steel Daytona or an Aquanaut far above list, a Calatrava or a Sea-Dweller below it.
Do luxury watches go up in value?
A small number do; most do not. Pre-owned prices fell for eleven straight quarters after their April 2022 peak and have risen every quarter since mid-2025, yet at the end of September 2026 the WatchCharts index was still about 29% below that peak. Outside Patek Philippe, Rolex and Audemars Piguet, the makers in Morgan Stanley's report averaged 26–38% below current retail in June 2026.
Is it better to sell a watch privately or to a dealer?
A private sale usually nets more but carries the risk of fraud and returns. A dealer pays less, in exchange for paying today; ask more than one for a written offer and set each against sold prices for the same reference.
How do I find out exactly what my watch is worth?
Find the reference number — between the lugs or on the case back — then look at sold prices, not asking prices, for that reference in similar condition and completeness. The maker pages give dated ranges; sold listings for your exact reference settle it.
The Lovenhall RegistryLovenhall Watch

Read the watch itself

These pages read the market. The instrument reads what you are holding — recognised from a photograph, with a range for its kind.

Free on iPhone, iPad & Android. An estimate, never an appraisal.
Or write to the house